Should Your Online Store Offer Free Shipping and Returns?
)
Free shipping sells. It also quietly rewrites your margin, your return rate, and your average order value, often before you've noticed any of the three moving.
TL;DR
Free shipping can work as a genuine conversion lever, but weigh the lift against what it costs on every sale, not just the ones it wins
Three things to weigh before committing: the hit to margin, the rise in returns, and the money left on the table from shoppers who'd have bought anyway
Asos and Nordstrom Rack show two different ways to structure it: a flat order threshold, or a paid membership
Free shipping on every item rarely makes sense, large or bulky items need their own cost-control approach
Thresholds, not blanket free shipping, are what most shoppers already expect
What to Consider Before Jumping on the Free Shipping Bandwagon
Free shipping can work as a conversion lever, but before you commit, weigh how much a waived delivery fee would lift your orders against what it would cost you on each sale.
Free Shipping Might Increase Sales, But It Could Kill Your Profit Margin
A Walker Sands survey found nine in ten shoppers name free shipping as their top incentive to buy. That pull is real, but it forces a choice: absorb the shipping cost, build it into the product price, or accept a thinner margin, and weigh that against whether the long-term value of the customer actually covers it.
Your Returns Could Skyrocket
Analysts estimate that roughly a third of online purchases get returned, and free shipping is part of why. It removes the one piece of friction that might have stopped an uncertain shopper from buying in the first place, which means more items ordered on a maybe and sent back on a no. Every one of those returns loses value moving back through the supply chain, and a damaged or opened item that can't be resold at full price eats the margin twice. Our returns management guide covers how to keep that volume from becoming its own operational problem.
You Could Be Leaving Money on the Table
Free shipping is also a discount handed to shoppers who were always going to buy. That's the cost side nobody budgets for: the conversion lift from undecided shoppers is real but hard to isolate from the giveaway to shoppers who needed no convincing at all, which is exactly why most sellers end up testing thresholds rather than guessing.
How Do Some Bigger Retailers Handle Free Shipping?
Asos
Asos currently offers free standard shipping to US customers on orders over $75, with standard shipping running $10 below that threshold.
Nordstrom Rack
Nordstrom Rack offers free shipping on most orders over $89. Its returns window runs 40 days from purchase, extended through mid-January for anything bought during the 2026 holiday season, by mail or free at a US store.
Should You Offer Free Shipping and Returns on All Orders?
Site-Wide Free Shipping Is Expensive
Work your shipping cost into your pricing before you commit to covering it everywhere. Free shipping across an entire catalogue hurts margin quickly, and since retaining an existing customer costs less than winning a new one, the giveaway has to be earning its keep rather than running on autopilot.
Free Delivery Does Not Make Sense for Certain Items
Small, light items like jewellery or makeup are cheap to ship either way, so waiving the fee saves the customer very little. Large or bulky items are the opposite problem. Shipping cost on them is real and it adds up fast, which is where this decision actually gets hard and where a flat site-wide promise does the most damage.
How to Keep the Cost of Shipping Large Items Down
Measure Accurately
Dimensional weight, not just actual weight, is what the major carriers price against, and each one calculates it differently. Getting an item's real dimensions right before you compare rates is the first place sellers lose money without realising it.
Pay More Now to Save Later
A slightly pricier courier with a strong reliability record costs less over time than a cheap one that loses or damages items. Every lost or damaged parcel becomes a return, a replacement and a support ticket. Opening accounts with several reliable couriers and comparing quotes directly is worth the up-front effort.
Use Specialist Couriers and the Right Packaging
A courier that specialises in your type of item usually beats a generalist on price and handling. Packaging matters just as much, because an oversized box inflates the dimensional weight and the price with it. Fitting the packaging to the item is free money saved.
Reduce the Number of Returns
Large items are expensive to ship in both directions, so a prevented return is worth more than an efficient one. Faster, better-informed support can offer an alternative before a customer commits to sending an item back, and keeping them updated on delivery status heads off the uncertainty that often ends in a return. Our guide on automating WISMO inquiries covers the update side of that.
Frequently asked questions
Should an online store offer free shipping? In most cases, yes, but on a threshold rather than site-wide. A threshold set just above your current average order value captures the conversion benefit while limiting the discount handed to shoppers who were already going to buy. A blanket offer applies the cost to every order, including the ones that needed no incentive.
Does free shipping increase returns? It increases the number of orders placed on a maybe, which is the type most likely to come back. The National Retail Federation estimated 19.3% of online sales would be returned in 2025 against 15.8% across all retail. Your own category-level return rate matters more than the national figure when deciding whether to extend free returns.
What is a good free shipping threshold? Set it above your current average order value, far enough that it moves basket size but not so far that most shoppers cannot reach it. Asos uses $75 for US standard shipping and Nordstrom Rack uses $89, both above a typical single-item order. Check what share of your existing orders already clears the number you are considering.
Should free shipping apply to large or bulky items? Usually not. Shipping cost on large items is substantial and carriers price on dimensional weight, so a site-wide promise is most expensive exactly where margin is thinnest. Excluding bulky categories, or setting a separate threshold for them, is more sustainable than absorbing the cost everywhere.
Is it better to offer free shipping or free returns? They are separate decisions with different cost profiles. Free shipping is a one-way cost you can model per order. Free returns is an open-ended cost driven by return rate, item condition on arrival and restocking, so it is the riskier of the two in categories with high return rates such as apparel.
How do I work out whether free shipping is actually profitable? Compare the margin on orders placed under the offer against the margin on comparable orders before it, and include the added return volume rather than just the shipping absorbed. If average order value rises but net margin per order falls, the threshold is set too low.
Where to Start
Cost it before you promise it. Work out your average shipping cost per order, your return rate by category, and the share of orders that already clear the threshold you are considering. Those three numbers tell you whether free shipping is a conversion lever or a discount you are handing to buyers who need no convincing.
Then set a threshold rather than a blanket offer, exclude or separately price your bulky categories, and watch return rate alongside average order value instead of celebrating the latter on its own. Start for free and track the returns and delivery contacts your shipping policy generates in one place.
)